Christian books: It’s not “just fiction”

For those who may not know the reasons discerning Christians consider the best-selling book The Shack heretical, Elizabeth Prata of The End Time has some information to share. As Amy Spreeman pointed out in her blog post “The Shack” to be the next blasphemous blockbuster film there are more than a dozen heresies in the book. The theological argument in The Shack, says Prata “is that God does not punish sin and everyone will eventually be reconciled to God.”

So my question is, why would any serious Christian waste their time and money to see a movie that outright blasphemes God?

Oh, but they will the minute the movie hits theaters March 3rd.

This piece is not only about The Shack.  Prata also examines Christian fiction in general.  She cautions that Christian fiction shapes a person’s theology and urges readers not to accept the argument “It’s just fiction.”

Here are Elizabeth’s thoughts on Christian fiction.  She writes:

I love to read. With the New Year and all the ‘Reading Challenges’ that emerge as people make decisions at the start of the year, I’d decided to go back to reading for pleasure. This is an activity that had fallen by the wayside as I got busier, and my eyes grew more tired at night. Aging. It’s not for sissies, lol.

I also decided to read the books that were on my own shelves to start with, rather than going out to buy a bunch of new books. Shop my own shelves, so to speak! So as I’d picked up that novel or this novel I’d had on my shelf since before salvation, and began to read them, I became dissatisfied. Sadly, the secular novels of today, even the literary ones, contain things my sanctifying soul objects to. Especially if there is profanity or blasphemy.

Are Christian books safer? Well, no. Take the book The Shack, for instance. This was a runaway bestseller back in 2007-2008 and onward. It was sold in Christian bookstores as a Christian book. Its author, William P. Young, wrote about a man who was staggering under heavy grief due to the kidnapping and death of his little daughter, which had happened in a derelict shack. One day the man received a handwritten note in his mailbox, with no stamp or postage, requesting his presence…in the shack. It turned out to have been an invitation from God. Curious, the man goes to the shack, where he also ‘meets’ Jesus and the Holy Spirit in addition to being greeted by ‘God.’ It turns out that according to the author’s presentation of the Trinity, God is a woman, as is the Holy Spirit. The book goes on to present discussions between the persons of the Trinity and the man, regarding sin, evil, salvation, judgment, and other doctrines. The book teaches that sin is its own judgment, that hell exists to purge away unbelief (not punish for sin), that there is universal reconciliation, and other aberrant, non-biblical doctrines.

Many credible leaders in the faith negatively reviewed the book. I reviewed it negatively also. A common rebuttal to our negative view of the book was, “Lighten up. It’s only fiction!” Or, “It’s only a novel!”

Dear reader, novels teach an author’s point of view, either subtly or overtly. It’s no different for Christian novels. Novels with Christian themes use narrative to teach. We must all be Bereans and check to see that these things in the ‘Christian’ book are so, in whatever form the doctrines are coming to us. Doctrine is taught in songs, poems, sermons, lessons, theological books…and fiction.

Below are three essays regarding Christian fiction and theology that flesh out these issues.  Continue reading

, , , , , ,

3 Responses to Christian books: It’s not “just fiction”

  1. Rapturesaint January 21, 2017 at 2:06 pm #

    A bible teacher once said, memorize scripture and strive to memorize a whole book of the Bible. To supplement your reading the bible, is to read a book from a Christian author.

    It may sound good biblical advise, but the books coming out in this era, will mess up your walk with God Almighty. That’s why I prefer not only to read my bible, but to be a good listener on very word of Scripture. Why? Because God is talking to me when I am reading the Bible. I want to be a good listener and not read the bible for the sake of reading it.
    It’s like when you were in grade school and the teacher is reading you a good story book, but your mind is in out of space. Take it very seriously when God is talking to you and not let your mind wonder.
    Read your holy bible and you’ll never go off your path in your walk with God almighty. Most especially this last days when we need “discernment.”

  2. Edwitness January 21, 2017 at 6:24 pm #

    For research you had to read it. But, other than for that purpose why would any Christian want to read a book that blasphemes God in such a way? I will never understand that.

  3. Bridgette Blumenthal January 31, 2017 at 1:25 pm #

    Yes, Reading the review has been enough for me. Gives me insight to know how to respond to those who ‘love’ the book!

Leave a Reply